Half a great movie

\"\"id=\"BLOGGER_PHOTO_ID_5362571091048107538\"On Thursday, I wrote a blog post comparing writing a movie to pitching a perfect game. Replayray took the time to write an interesting comment, in which he said:

i\’m not sure any movie is a perfect game. to quote Howard Hawks,\”there are no great movies,but a good movie has 3 great scenes and no bad ones\”.

His comment reminded me of a post on The A.V. Club blog entitled, My Year Of Flops Norm MacDonald’s Film Career Died For Your Sins Case File #133: Dirty Work. In it, Nathan Rabin wrote:

If a great movie is one with two great scenes and no bad ones, then Dirty Work is half a great movie. It contains more than its share of bad scenes, but it does have two brilliant ones.

What\’s your favorite half great movie?

2 thoughts on “Half a great movie”

  1. how about the 1st half of David Lynch's "Lost Highway"? after Balthazar Getty turns up in place of Bill Pullman in the jail cell, i couldn't help obsessing on when they replaced Samantha's husband with another "Darren" with nary a word.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

en_USEnglish
Scroll to Top